Caslon Analytics elephant logo title for 419 Scams note
home | about | site use | resources | publications | timeline   spacer graphic   blaw

overview

types

unbeatable

miracles

dictators

orphans

hitmen

chains

victims















related pages icon
related
Guides:


Security
& InfoCrime


Governance

Consumers



related pages icon
related
Profiles
& Notes:


Stalking

Messaging

Identity
Crime


section heading icon     hitmen

This page discusses the email and SMS 'hit-man' scam, the obverse of the Nigerian email scam

It covers -

subsection heading icon     introduction

Use of postal mail and the telephone system to extort money by threatening people is traditional (and as noted below has been addressed trhrough a range of enactments and technical measures). It is unsurprising, given the cheapness of email and SMS, that some scammers have turned the 419 routine on its head - threatening the recipient with harm unless money is paid rather than offering to share money with the recipient.

The so-called hit-man scam gained attention in late 2006, with the FBI in the US for example noting a substantial increase in the number of such messages.

Typically the scam involves an email threat warning the victim that he/she will be killed or injured unless the scammer receives several thousand dollars. The message often claims that the recipient - who is generically identified - has been followed by the scammer.

One threat provided to the FBI for example indicated

I have followed you closely for one week and three days now. ... Do not contact the police or F.B.I. or try to send a copy of this to them, because if you do I will know, and might be pushed to do what I have being paid to do.

As with initial approaches by 419 scammers the 'hit-men' messages are untargeted: the scammer simply sends a threat to every address on a list (which might be the same list used for offers to share Saddam Hussein or Yasser Arafat's loot) and trusts that there will be a response.

2008 saw proliferation of 'hitmen' messages by SMS. Australians for example received messages such as

Someone paid me to kill you. If you want me to spare you, I'll give you two days to pay $5000. If you inform the police or anybody, you will die. I am monitoring you

with t he scammer providing the unlucky recipient with a payment method and an email address for contact.

subsection heading icon     law

In Australia extortion of money through threats to kill/injure an individual or cause damage to property are illegal. Section 27 of the state Crimes Act 1958 in Victoria for example specifies that the perpetrator of 'extortion with threat to kill' (ie where a person who makes a demand of another person with a threat to kill or inflict injury) is guilty of an indictable offence.

Provisions in the state and territory criminal codes are underpinned by federal communications law.

The federal Criminal Code, updated through the Crimes Legislation Amendment (Telecommunications Offences & Other Measures) Act (No. 2) 2004, features offences of using a carriage service or a "postal or similar service" "to menace, harass or cause offence".

As noted elsewhere on this site, Section 471.11 of the Criminal Code Act 1995 makes it an offence to use a postal or similar service to make a threat.

471.11 (1) prohibits making a threat to kill if the author of that threat intends the person to fear that the threat will be carried out.

477.11 (2) covers postal threats to cause serious harm. In both subsections 'actual fear' not required: "it is not necessary to prove that the person receiving the threat actually feared that the threat would be carried out".





icon for link to next page     next page  (chains)




this site
the web

Google
version of June 2008
© Bruce Arnold
caslon.com.au | caslon analytics