Caslon Analytics elephant logo title for Portfolios note
home | about | site use | resources | publications | timeline   spacer graphic   Ketupa

overview

operators























related pages icon
related
Profiles:


Domain
Name
System


Monetisation

Tasting

Domain
Name
Prices


Search
Behaviour


Metadata

section heading icon     operators

This page considers questions about domain name portfolios and the portfolio sector.

It covers -

subsection heading icon     portfolio operators

Intelligent rulemaking in Australia means that local portfolio specialists have not achieved the scale and public profile of some of those overseas companies, which emphasise aggregation of large number of domains (particularly in the dot-com space) but promote themselves as having different business models.

Demand Media, for example, accounts for some 200,000 domain names and results from three acquisitions. One executive proclaimed that

We're really a media company. We're not going to build out all of the domains, but we'll use tools and technologies to create a better consumer experience on all our domains.

Cynics, fairly or otherwise, might question the uniqueness of that "better consumer experience".

Competitor NameMedia (formerly YesDirect and BuyDomains.com) similarly said that

The analogy we use is real estate. Our objective is to build the largest portfolio of undeveloped real estate on the Internet. Some of the sites we have will be held for resale. The best ones, the waterfront properties, we'll build businesses around. It's a content-light, user-friendly way for people to find what they want.

Marchex explains that

our direct navigation business is focused on building and monetizing a large network of vertical and local Web sites that are used by tens of millions of unique visitors each month. ... Marchex offers advertisers the ability to place paid search listings, graphical ad units, product feeds and branded content on its Direct Navigation Web sites, which can be targeted by category, subcategory, keyword, or domain.

Internet REIT (iREIT) - "veteran domainers, seasoned entrepreneurs and other industry experts" "leading the industry's transition from domain properties to media properties" - commented that

iREIT is in the business of acquiring "virtual real estate" - portfolios of Internet domain names. Our primary interest in purchasing domain names that generate natural traffic and current revenue (through parking, affiliate programs, PPC, CPM, or a combination of internet advertising sources). We are very selective about purchasing speculative domains (those requiring development to justify their price).

Demand Media, founded by former Intermix Media (MySpace) ceo Richard Rosenblatt, announced in 2007 that it had raised a further US$100 million, for an aggregate U$320 million to be invested in domain names, registrars and enterprises that publish or distribute user-produced content for "passionate verticals".

subsection heading icon     issues

The 'direct search' and domain name profile industry poses a number of issues, including -

  • viability
  • innovation
  • typosquatting
  • demographics
  • values
  • cost effectiveness

As with the dot-com bubble, a number of portfolios (and portfolio builders) appear to have been established on the basis that they will be acquired before it becomes clear that the developer will never recover the costs through monetisation or will run out of money to exploit those names.

More broadly, there is uncertainty about the business models used by some portfolio czars.

In 2004 Marchex quoted estimates that the size of the global search market was approximately US$4.5 billion, forecast to grow to $13.1 billion by 2008, with a claim that 'direct navigation' ("defined as typing a URL into a browser address bar or using a bookmark") "may represent 10% or more of this market". In 2006 RBC Capital estimated that direct navigation in the US would generate US$650 million in sales, "about 7.5 percent of all search revenue". Much of that figure was, however, attributed to revenue sharing with search engines such as Google for paid placement.

It is unclear whether consumers will continue to rely on direct navigation and thereby power growth of the industry. Several of the studies cited in our discussion of search engines, directories and search behaviour strongly indicate that web savvy (or merely experienced) users avoid direct navigation.

Proponents of direct navigation argue that online 'real estate' can be converted into "media properties". That argument is deeply problematical, given past difficulties faced by site owners who have sought to attract recurrent visits on the basis of a site's content. Becoming a 'media property' requires more than a name (or harvesting of traffic from other sites). That is presumably why some portfolio builders are seeking alliances with media organisations, alliances that are likely to benefit those organisations more than the builders.

The industry has proclaimed that it is experienced, innovative and professional. Claims of innovation are dubious, given that traffic harvesting appears to have been pioneered by the adult content sector. Portfolio builders are not alone in trying to add content/services (and thus a reason for a second visit) to domains that essentially consist only of a name. The vicissitudes of sites that have sought to become major B2C or B2B portals might lead to caution about hype from particular businesses, particularly when that hype centres on buzzwords such as Web 2.0.

subsection heading icon     landmarks

1999 NameMedia formed in Washington as YesDirect

2000 Oversee.net founded in San Francisco

2003 Marchex founded in Seattle

2003 acquires Enhance Interactive (formerly ah-ha.com)

2003 Marchex acquires SiteWise Marketing (TrafficLeader)

2004 Marchex acquires Name Development Ltd for US$164.2m

2004 Marchex acquires goClick.com for US$12.5m

2004 Marchex IPO

2005 Marchex acquires IndustryBrains (industrybrains.com) for US$30.6m

2005 Marchex acquires Pike Street Industries for US$16.5m

2005 NameMedia acquired by venture capital firms Highland Capital Partners and Summit Partners

2006 Demand Media founded with US$120m investment by Oak Investment Partners and Spectrum Equity Partners

2006 Marchex acquires Open List Inc (openlist.com) for US$13m

2006 Internet REIT buys Netster.com

2006 Demand Media acquires travel and sports niche site operator Hillclimb Media

2006 Demand Media gains US$100m investment led by 3i

2006 Demand Media buys domain registrar eNom

2006 Marchex acquires AreaConnect LLC for US$16m

2006 Demand Media acquires eHow Inc

2006 Internet Business Group hypes £1.1m acquisition of 'cheap' names

2006 NameMedia gains equity financing from Highland Capital Partners and Summit Partners venture capital groups and US$100m debt financing from Goldman Sachs

2007 Demand Media acquires video host ExpertVillage.com

2007 Demand Media announces that it has raised US$320m investment in preceding 16 months.



::



this site
the web

Google

 

version of June 2007
© Bruce Arnold
caslon.com.au | caslon analytics